Three Chinese electric cars can advertise three different range numbers for what looks like the same battery. One says 490 km, another says 427 km, a third says 520 km. None of them is lying. They are using different test cycles, different market specifications, or both. The number is only meaningful when you know which cycle produced it.

The three cycles a buyer will meet

WLTP is the Worldwide Harmonised Light Vehicles Test Procedure, a global technical regulation developed under the United Nations. It replaced the older NEDC cycle in the European Union from 2017 and is used for type approval in Europe and several other markets. It is a laboratory cycle with a longer, more dynamic speed trace than NEDC, but it is still a laboratory cycle.

CLTC is the China Light-duty Vehicle Test Cycle, published as the Chinese national standard GB/T 38146.1-2019. It was built from Chinese road data and is used in Chinese fuel-consumption and electric-range test methods. Its speed profile and idle share reflect Chinese traffic conditions, not European motorway use.

NEDC is the older New European Driving Cycle. It is still quoted in some markets and by some importers, especially where a vehicle was type-approved before WLTP or where the local regulator still accepts it. NEDC is shorter and less dynamic than WLTP, which is why its numbers are often higher.

The same car, two numbers

BYD’s European release for the Dolphin quotes a WLTP combined range of 310 km to 427 km, depending on battery and version. BYD’s Hong Kong page for the Dolphin quotes a 490 km NEDC range with a 60.48 kWh battery. The car is recognisably the same model; the test cycle and market specification are not.

MG’s European MG4 brochure quotes up to 520 km WLTP for the longest-range version, while its German-market brochure lists a 51 kWh Standard version at 350 km WLTP and a 64 kWh Comfort at 450 km. Same nameplate, different battery, different number.

These examples are not anomalies. They are the normal output of a system in which manufacturers homologate different specifications for different markets and quote the cycle that market requires.

Why the gap exists

A range figure is the output of a test procedure, not a property of the battery alone. The procedure fixes the speed trace, ambient temperature, start condition, tyre pressure, load and use of climate control. Change the procedure and the number changes. Change the battery, motor, final drive or wheel size and the number changes again.

Real-world range then diverges further because the road does not follow a laboratory trace. Motorway speed, cold weather, headwind, passengers, roof bars, heating and battery age all take a share. A car that delivers its WLTP number in a mild city commute may deliver materially less in a winter motorway run. That is physics and use, not fraud.

How to compare two cars honestly

  1. Compare the same cycle. A WLTP figure against a CLTC figure is not a comparison. A WLTP figure against an NEDC figure is not a comparison either.
  2. Compare the same battery and trim. The headline range usually belongs to the largest battery. Check the battery capacity in kWh and the trim name.
  3. Ask for usable capacity. A 60 kWh pack may not give 60 kWh of usable energy. The buffer matters for charging time and daily range.
  4. Look at the charging curve, not just the peak. A 144 kW peak that tapers quickly can be slower on a trip than a lower but flatter curve.
  5. Treat the number as a laboratory result. Use it to rank cars on the same cycle, then subtract a realistic margin for your climate, speed and load. Do not treat it as a guarantee.

What the regulator actually says

The UNECE global technical regulation defines WLTP as a harmonised procedure for measuring emissions, fuel consumption and energy consumption. It does not promise a real-world range. The Chinese standard defines the CLTC speed profile; it does not promise that a Chinese buyer will achieve the CLTC number in Beijing traffic or on a Shanghai expressway.

That is why the useful question is not “which car has the biggest number?” but “which car has the biggest number on the cycle I can compare, with the battery I can buy, and how does that number hold up in my use?”

The short version

WLTP, CLTC and NEDC are different rulers. A 490 km NEDC figure, a 427 km WLTP figure and a 520 km WLTP figure can all be true at the same time for different cars or versions. Compare like with like, check the battery and trim, and budget for a real-world margin. The headline is a starting point, not an ownership forecast.

This guide explains test cycles and market scoping. It is not a statement that any particular vehicle will achieve a particular range in real use. Confirm the local homologated figure and battery specification with the importer.

Sources

Facts in this article are checked against the primary sources below. Specifications are market-specific; always confirm the final specification with the local dealer before purchase.

  1. www.byd.comhttps://www.byd.com/eu/blog/International-press-hit-the-road-with-all-new-BYD-DOLPHIN.html
  2. www.byd.comhttps://www.byd.com/en-hk/car/dolphin.html
  3. unece.orghttps://unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/trans/main/wp29/wp29r-1998agr-rules/ECE-TRANS-180a15e.pdf
  4. std.samr.gov.cnhttps://std.samr.gov.cn/gb/search/gbDetailed?id=95A47695C5614F2CE05397BE0A0AB3E0

Written by

AutoBridge Editor

More from this author